Discontinuity in Learning: Dewey, Herbart And Education As Transformation

"This book opens new doors to the understanding of the learning process, shedding unexpected light on J. F. Herbart's influence on John Dewey's work. Dr English enables the reader to make new sense of the importance of uncertainty and struggle in the learning process. Revealing unexpected connections between J. F. Herbart and John Dewey's work, she enhances our understanding of transformation, tact, and perfectibility. Engaging with this text releases the reader's understanding of learning. This text holds great relevance for the active classroom."
Maxine Greene, William F. Russell Professor Emerita in the Foundations of Education, Teachers College, Columbia University

"Discontinuity in Learning will deepen scholarly understanding of two significant philosophers on education and clarify important concepts - negativity, transformation, active remembering, pedagogical tact, perfectibility, recognition of the other, and so on - with which parents, teachers, and educational leaders can help the young manage their educational experience. Andrea English writes about Herbart and Dewey with an unusually full command of both German and Anglo-American scholarship. The book presents a different, more authentic Herbart than the old Herbartian simulacra, and it renews the reading of Dewey by putting him in a context in which experience appears riskier and more discontinuous and emergent than it does in a bland progressive optimism. The book will be a valuable addition to scholarship in the philosophy of education."
Robert McClintock, Emeritus Professor in the Historical and Philosophical Foundations of Education, Teachers College, Columbia University

"Andrea English's well-crafted, sophisticated study accomplishes several valuable aims. It elucidates significant similarities between the influential work on education of John Dewey and of the nineteenth-century German educationist J. F. Herbart. In so doing, the book reminds us of the power and originality in the latter's pioneering work. At the same time, the author brings into productive dialogue contemporary theories of learning and teaching in English- and German-speaking philosophy of education. Last but hardly least, English's study contributes in multiple ways to our understanding of why difficulty, disorientation, doubt, and the like - what she calls the 'discontinuities' in learning - are indispensable in any meaningful process of human growth."
David T. Hansen, Professor of Philosophy and Education, Teachers College, Columbia University

"English has done an admirable job of introducing and explaining the theoretical ideas presented in the first portion of the book. Even more impressive is the way that she weaves these ideas into the development of the second part. This artful weaving allows the reader to consider how notions of discontinuity can benefit teachers and learners alike ... Recommended ..."
J. A. Helfer, Choice

"... hugely enjoyable, well researched, well informed, well written and deeply provocative in the way it compellingly exhorts our attention to examine our core beliefs as educators and to urgently address the future direction of education in the world today."
Gifted Education International

In this groundbreaking book, Andrea English argues that discontinuous experiences, such as uncertainty and struggle, are essential to learning. Dr. English presents a fresh take on contemporary educational issues through insightful readings of the works of two seminal thinkers in philosophy of education - nineteenth-century German philosopher J. F. Herbart and American Pragmatist John Dewey.